FBA vs. Merchant Fulfilled: Complete Comparison for Amazon Sellers

FBA or FBM

The goal of your Amazon business is to grow sales and improve your bottom line. The question is whether Fulfillment By Amazon (FBA) or Fulfillment By Merchant (FBM) is the best route for your business. When you first register as a seller on Amazon you can set up your account as an FBA or FBM. What many sellers do not realize is that you can actually register for both, which will double your exposure and sales opportunities.

The following infographic provides a comprehensive comparison for Amazon sellers trying to decide between FBA or FBM. When looking at FBA vs. FBM, it is important to remember that Amazon businesses are not one-size-fits-all, so fulfillment methods need to align with your business goals and needs.

Infographic Amazon FBA vs FBM - Feedvisor

 

Difference Between FBA and MFN

When looking at the differences between FBA vs. merchant fulfilled network (MFN), it will be critical to consider the size of your operation and what kinds of items you sell. Sellers who utilize Fulfillment by Amazon pay fees to store their products in Amazon fulfillment centers. With FBA, Amazon handles the shipping and fulfillment, as well as customer service and returns. MFN refers to sellers shipping their own products directly to the customer from their own business, home, or warehouse location after receiving orders from Amazon.

As far as popularity is concerned, FBA sellers can better stand out from their competition and win the Buy Box more frequently because they can offer Amazon’s Prime shipping option and access Amazon’s shipping and fulfillment networks worldwide. However, it is a costly program to participate in, with monthly storage fees and long-term storage fees.

However, small businesses that are starting out and don’t have the ability to pay all of the associated FBA fees might be more suited for MFN. They can package and ship their products however they want and are therefore responsible for picking, packing, shipping, and customer service.

In addition to Fulfilment by Merchant, there is a new, rapidly growing MFN fulfillment method — Seller Fulfilled Prime. When analyzing FBA vs. merchant fulfilled via SFP, these two fulfillment methods are regarded by Amazon to have the same customer-first performance metrics and require sellers to maintain the Prime promise (ability to ship to customers with free, two-day delivery, whether it’s from an FBA location or a seller’s own warehouse). SFP allows qualified Amazon sellers with Professional seller accounts to display the Amazon Prime badge on orders fulfilled via their own warehouse or third-party logistics providers.

Fulfillment By Amazon

Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) is simply using the services provided by Amazon rather than your own resources. The program allows sellers to ship their merchandise to Amazon where items are stored in warehouses until they sell.

When to Choose FBA

FBA is better for:

  • High-volume sellers
  • Retailers prepared to drop the cost to the lowest possible profit point

Advantages to FBA

  • FBA Sellers almost always get the Buy Box, which is the ideal situation for any product
  • Amazon takes care of customer service and shipping
  • Conversions are generally higher because people trust Amazon to take care of them
  • They store the inventory for you and do the picking from their warehouses
  • Retail operation open 24/7
  • Much larger target audience
  • Comparatively shallow learning curve thanks to a plethora of support materials available on the internet
  • Super Saver and Amazon Prime Membership shipping benefits
  • Simplified returns process
  • More free time to grow the business
  • Great for retailers selling large, heavy or low-priced items where packaging is labor intensive and independent shipping costs may be prohibitive

Fulfillment By Merchant

When to Choose FBM

FBM is better for:

Advantages to FBM

  • Seller maintains a sense of control over the business
  • Margins are greater
  • Opportunity to build an independent brand is more feasible
  • Less unavoidable losses due to changes in Amazon policies
  • Less paperwork, particularly when dealing with non-sales-tax states
  • Freedom to run the business exactly as seller chooses
  • More control over your inventory
  • No unexpected costs
  • Easier to maintain both online and offline retail activity with one inventory

Which Option Is Best for You?

When determining if Fulfillment by Amazon, Fulfillment by Merchant, or a combination of the two when SFP is incorporated is the right choice for your business, you should consider the size of your business and any growth potential, the product categories that you sell, and what aspects of your business you are looking to invest the most resources in.

The Amazon FBA Calculator is a useful tool to help you decide whether to use Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) or pursue an alternate fulfillment method. With the calculator, you have the ability to either compare FBA to FBM (Fulfillment by Merchant) or to simply calculate the fees involved with FBA.